Britology Watch: Deconstructing \’British Values\’

4 May 2009

Carol Ann Duffy: First Female (correction, first Scottish) Poet Laureate

With all the hoo-ha last week about Carol Ann Duffy being the first woman appointed to the position of ‘Poet Laureate of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland’, the fact that she is also the first Scot to hold the position was conveniently glossed over.

I’ve got nothing against the woman. I don’t know her work, although people I know who have read it speak highly of it. Nor is it altogether inappropriate that a Scot should be appointed, as the geographical extent of the post does comprise the whole of the UK. Nor is it even especially surprising that Carol Ann Duffy is the first Scottish poet to have been thus honoured, as the position enjoys a long heritage in English history, going back to the role of versificator regis in the medieval English court, and later being named ‘Poet Laureate of the Kingdom of England’.

Fair enough, I suppose: if the UK can have a Scottish PM, why not also have a Scottish Poet Laureate? Well, in the case of the PM, as we know, the problem is that Scotland and Wales have their own First Ministers to deal with domestic policy issues; so that it is inappropriate for someone elected in Scotland to have governmental responsibility for English domestic issues when they are not accountable for their actions in that respect to any English voters.

In the case of the PL, the problem is that there are separate ‘national poets’ for Scotland and Wales now. I say ‘now’ as shorthand for ‘after devolution’: the first ‘Scots Makar’ having been appointed by the Scottish Parliament in 2004; and the first ‘National Poet for Wales’ having been appointed in 2005. And Carol Ann Duffy is the first ‘British’ Poet Laureate to have been nominated since those dates. So at the very time when Scotland and Wales have gained their own national parliaments and national poets, we in England get an unaccountable Scottish PM who denies the very existence of England, and a Scottish Poet Laureate whose remit covers the whole of the UK, not England in particular.

I trust that she will refrain from writing poetry that claims to speak on behalf of England or to represent an authentic English voice – unlike Gordon Brown, who does abrogate the right to represent us when he doesn’t. But then doesn’t the land of Shakespeare deserve its own present-day national poet? Any suggestions?



  1. […] Original post by David […]

    Pingback by Carol Ann Duffy: First Female (correction, first Scottish) Poet Laureate — 4 May 2009 @ 2.56 am | Reply

  2. Whilst she was born in Glasgow Carol Ann Duffy was raised in England and educated in the English system. She has lived mostly in England. Yes she is Scottish by birth but it seems damned churlish not to allow her to write poetry which expresses the identity she has been nurtured within. Also if you haven’t read something writing about it seems rather ignorant…doncha think?

    Just saying.

    Much love Sarah

    Comment by Sarah — 24 October 2009 @ 4.26 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: